The banking industry changes proposed by the treasurer last week in an effort to introduced more competition to Australian lending does not worry the big banks. In fact after the proposed changes were announced bank shared jumped in a indication that the proposal aids rather than hinders the big banks.
In fact, the proposal to ban loan exit fees will only leave the smaller lenders bleeding.
The big four banks have already started to abolish these fees because they already take in so much money and carry such profit margins that they would not be affected in the least by the abolition of these fees.
For example, the standard variable rate among the big four currently sits between 7.67 per cent and 7.86 per cent, according to data from infochoice.com.au.
Compare this with some of the cheaper rates offered by non-bank lenders such as QuickDirect, HomeStar and Resi Mortgage Corporation. These rates are as low as 6.65 per cent and the majority are at least half a percentage point below the big banks.
Smaller lenders offer better deals on rates so they charge bigger exit fees, commonly called “deferred establishment fees” (a name that just confuses everybody).
These exit fees can be several thousand dollars because they aim to deter borrowers from refinancing early before the smaller lenders get a chance to profit from the transaction.
Mortgage and Finance Association of Australia chief executive Phil Naylor sums it up nicely: “Non-bank lenders have been able to offer consumers very competitive interest rates by deferring some of the setup costs into deferred establishment fees which are paid only if there is an early termination of the loan”.
“Exit fees may in fact be replaced by establishment fees, making it harder for borrowers to get a loan,” Naylor says.
Or they may simply lead to non-bank lenders increasing their rates to be closer to those of the banks.
Removal of the exit fees is not at all in the interests of the consumers but rather is a tool to assist the already big and powerful at thew cost of the smaller players.
In a similar vein is the move to give the ACCC powers to prosecute banks “signalling” rate rises to each other.
The banks’ response to that law will be to simply shut up and say nothing at all about their views on interest rate movements, which will leave consumers less informed.